Eli Manning's Hall of Fame Snub Sparks Debate
Eli Manning, the former New York Giants quarterback, was not selected for the Pro Football Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility in 2025. Despite being one of 15 semifinalists, Manning did not advance to the final seven candidates for consideration. This decision has sparked widespread debate, as Manning’s career includes two Super Bowl victories, both of which earned him Super Bowl MVP honors. He is one of only six quarterbacks in NFL history with multiple Super Bowl MVP awards, joining legends like Tom Brady and Joe Montana.
Manning’s Hall of Fame candidacy is polarizing. Supporters highlight his two iconic Super Bowl wins over the New England Patriots, his durability (210 consecutive starts), and his impressive career statistics, including ranking 11th all-time in passing yards and touchdowns. However, critics point to his lack of All-Pro selections, a career record of 117-117 as a starter, and his three-time league-leading interceptions as reasons for his exclusion.
The competition for Hall of Fame induction is fierce, with quarterbacks like Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, and Ben Roethlisberger becoming eligible in the coming years. Brees, in particular, is expected to be a first-ballot inductee, further complicating Manning’s path to Canton. Analysts suggest it may take until 2029 or later for Manning to garner the necessary 80% support from the selection committee.
Manning, for his part, has expressed peace with the decision, stating that it does not diminish his pride in his career. Hall of Fame voters and football analysts remain divided, with some arguing that his postseason heroics and longevity should outweigh his regular-season shortcomings. While his eventual induction seems likely, the timeline remains uncertain.
When will Eli Manning be selected for the Pro Football Hall of Fame?
Settle in because this might be a long journey
www.bigblueview.com
Eli Manning isn't elected to Pro Football Hall of Fame on first ballot. His case for Canton.
Eli Manning was not selected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility. Here is the case for and and against him.
www.usatoday.com
Eli Manning speaks out about Pro Football Hall of Fame snub
.
www.on3.com
Eli Manning Once Pranked Former Teammate Saquon Barkley by Putting Grass in His Mouth
Eli and Peyton Manning joined Jason and Travis Kelce on the ‘New Heights’ podcast, and Eli revealed how he used to prank NFL rookies ahead of their pr
people.com
Victor Cruz doesn’t dance around whether Eli Manning belongs in the Hall of Fame
The former Giants WR talked about his quarterback’s Hall of Fame candidacy, golf, and much more.
www.sbnation.com
Eli Manning says 'only one team' he'd take an ownership stake in: The New York Giants
Former New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning told CNBC he's interested in becoming a minority owner of his former team, if the Mara family is willin
www.cnbc.com
The never-before-revealed details of the infamous Eli Manning draft-day trade
With the Chargers’ and Giants’ trade now 15 years in the rearview mirror, A.J. Smith and Ernie Accorsi share inside info of the Eli Manning-Philip Riv
www.sbnation.com